Faroe Islanders have hunted and consumed pilot whales for the last millennia. Hunting whale has always been an important backbone of the national identity and community spirt. A food source for which the Faroese must be truly indebted in times of survival and oppression. However, since the industrial revolution, the globalised world has slowly polluted their marine environment. Harmful contaminates, such as mercury, have bio-accumulated up the marine food chain. Now, the very same poisons which harm the whales, now threaten the Islanders eating them. Pilot whale meat and blubber is ‘no longer fit for human consumption’, but 70% of the nation still consume this toxic cultural delicacy. Time, education and cultural respect is now required from the international community. The mercury pollution remains the biggest factor in ending the whale hunt and past environmental activism has only failed the whales in the Faroe Islands. A new approach is essential if we are to see the end of this historic hunt and the risk of a human health crisis in the next generation.